New Buffalo, MI

Featured Community Listings

Get new listing alerts delivered to your inbox.

Market Report

Open Homes

Listings

New Buffalo, MI Homes for Sale

For Sale Recently Sold

46 Results

$699,000

4175 Creek Drive
New Buffalo, MI 49117

5
Beds

2 | 1
Baths

1,506
SqFt

(31)

#26022573 | House

$449,900

310 Oselka Drive #155
New Buffalo, MI 49117

1
Beds

1
Baths

750
SqFt

(22)

Virtual Tour

#26022373 | Condo

$630,000

217 W Merchant Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

3 | 1
Baths

2,063
SqFt

(30)

#26021980 | Condo

$2,250,000

210 E Water Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

4
Beds

4 | 1
Baths

2,960
SqFt

(54)

#26021952 | House

$985,000

30 Briarwood Trail
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

4
Baths

2,906
SqFt

(53)

#26021854 | House

$449,000

18840 Spring Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

6
Beds

3 | 1
Baths

2,991
SqFt

(29)

#26021686 | House

$279,000

309 S 11th Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

2
Beds

1
Baths

725
SqFt

(16)

#26020705 | House

$825,000

14458 Wolf Lane
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

2 | 1
Baths

2,455
SqFt

(31)

#26020691 | House

$749,000

28 Walden Way
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

3
Baths

2,028
SqFt

(44)

#26020679 | House

$3,850,000

331 Marquette Drive
New Buffalo, MI 49117

6
Beds

4 | 1
Baths

5,538
SqFt

(60)

#26020121 | House

$1,700,000

51212 Deer Park Drive
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

3 | 1
Baths

3,844
SqFt

(31)

Virtual Tour

#26019896 | House

$365,000

17 S Willard Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

2
Baths

1,440
SqFt

(13)

#26019862 | House

$2,895,000

10520 Marquette Drive
New Buffalo, MI 49117

6
Beds

3 | 1
Baths

4,600
SqFt

(12)

#26019822 | House

$425,000

418 S Mayhew Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

4
Beds

2
Baths

2,170
SqFt

(43)

#26019566 | House

$659,900

4160 Comanche Trail
New Buffalo, MI 49117

2
Beds

2
Baths

1,100
SqFt

(22)

#26019410 | House

$499,900

321 S Taylor Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

1
Baths

1,602
SqFt

(33)

Virtual Tour

#26018626 | House

$352,000

923 Bell Avenue
New Buffalo, MI 49117

4
Beds

2
Baths

1,134
SqFt

(27)

#26018475 | House

$590,000

121 E Michigan Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

Beds

Baths

N/A
SqFt

(38)

#26018412 | House

$745,000

200 Marx Drive
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

2
Baths

2,100
SqFt

(21)

#26017925 | House

$330,000

14 Lighthouse Point
New Buffalo, MI 49117

0
Beds

1
Baths

400
SqFt

(20)

#26017384 | Condo

$539,900

49209 Howard Avenue
New Buffalo, MI 49117

4
Beds

2
Baths

1,892
SqFt

(24)

#26016287 | House

$899,000

4046 Hillside Trail
New Buffalo, MI 49117

4
Beds

3 | 1
Baths

2,518
SqFt

(36)

#25043853 | House

$400,000

209 S Marshall Street
New Buffalo, MI 49117

3
Beds

1 | 1
Baths

1,082
SqFt

(7)

#26014833 | House

$192,600

17859 Behner Road
New Buffalo, MI 49117

1
Beds

1
Baths

N/A
SqFt

(31)

#26014810 | House

MichRIC, LLC data last updated at May 18, 2026, 6:18 AM ET